From CS294-10 Visualization Sp11
Lecture on Feb 2, 2011
- Perception in visualization. Healey. (html)
- Graphical perception. Cleveland & McGill. (jstor)(Google Scholar)
- Chapter 3: Layering and Separation, In Envisioning Information. Tufte.
- Gestalt and composition. In Course #13, SIGGRAPH 2002. Durand. (1-up pdf) (6-up pdf)
- The psychophysics of sensory function. Stevens. (pdf)
- Crowdsourcing Graphical Perception: Using Mechanical Turk to Assess Visualization Design. Heer & Bostock. ACM CHI 2010. (html)
188.8.131.52 - Feb 09, 2011 01:56:43 pm
Regarding Figure 29 in the Cleveland & McGill paper, I would argue that this graph and a more traditional heat or patch map serve two different purposes. Although in this map it is easier to compare the murder rates from one state to another it does not take advantage of the preattentive processing described in the Healey paper. A traditional heat map gives a good overview of quantitative variables but it allows for only minimal comparison of similar values. This type of map gives a poor overview of quantitative variables and requires postattentive processing for finding anomolies, but allows for much more nuanced comparison of individual states' values even when the difference between them is minimal.